Whimzees and Greenies Stack Up Close for Big Dogs
Earthbones gets points for its limited ingredients and natural enzymes that tackle bad breath right at the source, but Whimzees match that with a grain-free, veggie formula that's just as plant-based and easy on sensitive stomachs. Their unique knobs and grooves scrape plaque better on large breeds' bigger teeth, and they last longer for power chewers who might polish off Earthbones too fast. Greenies, on the other hand, bring a proven edge with their toothbrush-like shape that flexes to hit back molars and gumlines where buildup hides - something Earthbones' standard design doesn't emphasize as much. Both alternatives digest well, with Greenies at 94% digestibility, avoiding the tummy upset you sometimes hear about with denser chews. Price-wise, you'll save compared to Earthbones since Whimzees and Greenies packs go for less per treat, especially in bulk for large sizes.
Unboxing That First Chew Session
You rip open the bag, and the earthy smell hits - nothing artificial, just veggies and maybe a hint of mint from the breath fresheners in Whimzees or Greenies. No assembly needed; these are ready-to-give sticks or bones sized for large dogs, around 6-8 inches long to match those powerful jaws. Your dog sniffs, grabs it quick, and starts gnawing within seconds - no real learning curve beyond watching to make sure they don't wolf it down whole. First week, you notice less gunk on their teeth after a few sessions, and the Z or brush shape makes it fun for them to twist and grip.
Related: Learn more: Is Earthbones Dental for Large Dogs worth buying in 2026
Months In, the Real Chew Test
After weeks, Whimzees hold their shape better than softer options, softening just enough to clean without crumbling into a mess on your floor - though you still sweep up bits from enthusiastic large-dog chomps. Greenies might vanish faster for aggressive chewers, but they keep delivering on tartar reduction without wearing down teeth. Durability shines with both; no cracking or quick disintegration like flimsier treats, and maintenance is simple - just store the bag sealed to keep them fresh. Over months, breath stays fresher, plaque buildup slows, but you might rotate flavors if your dog gets picky. They don't degrade much, staying effective till the pack's gone.
Related: Learn more: What to consider when buying Earthbones Dental for Large ...
If Earthbones feels overpriced, grab Whimzees for large dogs first - they're the toughest match for heavy chewers without breaking the bank.
